Skip to content

Financial Literacy: Fixed versus variable rate mortgages

If you’re looking to buy a new property, refinance, or renew an existing mortgage, chances are you’re considering either a fixed or variable rate mortgage.
Financial Literacy Powell River
Getty image.

If you’re looking to buy a new property, refinance, or renew an existing mortgage, chances are you’re considering either a fixed or variable rate mortgage. Figuring out which one is the best is entirely up to you; it has a lot to do with your tolerance to risk and the ability to withstand payment increase.

Firstly, let’s talk about the fixed-rate mortgage as this is most common and most heavily endorsed by the banks.

With a fixed-rate mortgage, your interest rate is “fixed” for a certain term, anywhere from six months to 10 years, with the typical term being five years. If market rates fluctuate anytime after you sign on the dotted line, your mortgage rate won’t change. You’re a rock; your rate is set in stone. Typically, a fixed-rate mortgage has a higher rate than a variable.

Alternatively, a variable rate is not set in stone; instead, it fluctuates with the market.

The variable rate is a component (either plus or minus) to the prime rate. So if the prime rate (set by the government and banks) is 2.45 per cent and the current variable rate is prime minus .45 per cent, your effective rate would be two per cent. Now, if three months after you sign your mortgage documents, the prime rate goes up by .25 per cent, your rate would then move to 2.25 per cent. Typically, variable rates come with a five-year term, although some lenders do allow you to go with a shorter term.

So at first glance, the fixed rate seems to be the safe bet, even if you have to pay a little more to lock-in, and the variable rate appears to be the wild card. But this might not be the case.

Here’s the problem, what this doesn’t account for is the fact that a fixed-rate mortgage and a variable-rate mortgage have two very different ways of calculating the penalty should you need to break your mortgage.

If you decide to break your variable rate mortgage, regardless of how much you have left on your term, you will end up owing three months interest, which works out to roughly two to two and a half payments.

With a fixed-rate mortgage, you will pay the greater of either three months interest or what is called an interest rate differential penalty. As every lender calculates its interest rate differential penalty differently, and that calculation is based on market fluctuations and the remaining time left on your term, there is no way to guess at what that penalty will be.

However, with that said, it won’t be pleasant. If you’ve ever heard horror stories of banks charging outrageous penalties to break a mortgage, this is an interest rate differential. It’s not uncommon to see penalties 10 times the amount with a fixed-rate mortgage compared to a variable rate mortgage. There is a reason the banks like people in five-year term, fixed-rate mortgages.

The goal of any mortgage should be to pay the least amount of money to the lender as possible. So while a fixed-rate mortgage might provide you with a more stable payment, if “life happens” and you need to break your mortgage, you might end up paying considerably more in fees than you would have ever paid by taking a variable rate.

Now, something to think about related to the times we find ourselves in, mid- or post-COVID-19, the Bank of Canada has indicated that rates will remain low for years to come, making the chances of an increase in prime very slim. Also, historically, variables have come out ahead over the last 40 years.

Cait Holmes is a mortgage broker in Powell River.