Les Leyne: Balancing right to protest and rule of law is a tightrope walk

The reason Premier John Horgan ducked all public comment about the legislature blockade was because he was too steamed to stand in front of a microphone.

He didn’t say it in so many words, but that was the impression left Wednesday after a lengthy news conference in the aftermath of the unprecedented attempt to shut down the seat of government.

article continues below

He had cancelled a scheduled media appearance and instead issued a news release late in that very tense day after hundreds of protesters jostled and blocked workers trying to enter the legislature.

“I chose not to talk directly to you yesterday because of my personal feelings at the time,” he told reporters during an extended after-action report.

It was a lot more restrained than if it had been conducted in the heat of the day-long shoving match. Because they were “strong” feelings, held by many, he said.

There was one brief glimpse of what might have been. Asked about the role of Victoria city councillor Ben Isitt, who attended and supported the protest and at one point criticized his own police department’s approach to it, Horgan said: “My thoughts on that individual are not printable.”

But after sleeping on it for a night, Horgan decided to try to walk the tightrope between supporting the fundamental right to protest and recognizing the rule of law.

It’s a tough balancing act and isn’t going to get any easier, as more protest blockades appear to be in the works, as early as this Friday. They’re going to push him steadily toward emphasizing the need to recognize rule of law, if Wednesday’s appearance was any indication.

Not that he has much choice.

The blockade was unacceptable to him and the vast majority of British Columbians, he said. Peaceful demonstrations are a fundamental right, “but to have a group of people say to others: ‘You are illegitimate, you are not allowed in here, you are somehow a sellout to the values of Canadians’ is just plain wrong.”

He stressed how unprecedented the attempt to shut down the legislature was, compared to the protests he routinely used to attend in the past.

“Game-changer,” was the phrase he settled on to describe it.

Horgan said he is not responsible for security or law enforcement but was “sincerely apologetic” to the legislature staff who had to endure the blockade.

“These are extraordinary times, these are extraordinary events.”

Horgan also dwelled on the Indigenous rights aspect of the pipeline protest, where it’s linked to some hereditary Wet’suwet’en chiefs’ opposition to the line, despite widespread support from elected Indigenous leaders.

He said: “I don’t believe for a minute, knowing Indigenous peoples broadly speaking as I do, that what they viewed yesterday in their name was how they want to go forward.”

Coming just a few months after the legislature unanimously adopted the UN declaration on Indigenous rights as the new template for all future dealings with First Nations, the demonstrations raise fresh new questions about how it’s all going to work.

In the premier’s view, “the only way forward is through hard work and commitment to each other.” Horgan also appeared sensitive to any criticism that he didn’t take any obvious action to put an end to the blockade. “I don’t want to live in a society where politicians direct police to take action against other citizens without appropriate reason for doing so. That’s why we have courts. That’s why injunctions are sought.”

He was outlining due process in the abstract, but it may become a reality.

Just So You Know: The NDP is wracked with conflicting emotions on the protests, given their previous warm relationships with some of the anti-pipeline factions. The two-member Green caucus — bullied like everyone else on the way in Tuesday — was profoundly troubled by the showdown, too. But they’re less conflicted, because they opposed LNG from the start and still do.

Green MLAs Adam Olsen and Sonia Fursteneau — and newly independent Andrew Weaver — will be watching the government’s response closely if the attempted shutdowns continue. Their support is still crucial to the government.

Right to protest versus rule of law isn’t the only tightrope Horgan is walking.

lleyne@timescolonist.com

Copyright © Powell River Peak

PEAK POLL

Should BC Ministry of Health provide up-to-date information in relation to the number of new and active COVID-19 cases within our region?

or  view results

COVID-19 outbreak prompts Powell River Regional Hospital District to write letters

Popular Peak

Community Events Calendar